Moving Beyond the Billable Hour Takes More Than a New Fee Structure

Baker McKenzie’s push toward alternative fee arrangements is getting attention and raising a familiar question:
Is this the beginning of the end for the billable hour?

My question is more practical:
“Are firms and clients prepared to do the work that makes those arrangements successful?”

In his recent Law360 article, Baker McKenzie’s Billing Shift Won’t Kick Off Industry Switch, Daniel Moritz-Rabson explores what the announcement could mean for the broader legal market. I added a perspective that often gets lost in the discussion: agreeing on a price requires understanding what that price covers, and a process for handling what changes.

As I told Law360:

“For both parties to be able to assess non-hourly fees, they need agreed upon scope development and scope change processes. Neither of those exist at scale for either party. So how can anyone say when a fee is fair or not? Many clients even say under fixed fees they will not accept any changes to it once it is set.”

That’s the work ahead. A fixed fee does not make uncertainty disappear. Firms and clients need to define the scope, discuss assumptions, and agree on how they will respond when the work changes. Those capabilities are essential to making alternative fees sustainable for both sides.

The announcement starts a conversation. Execution will determine whether it delivers meaningful change. I have transcribed the article, and included a link to Law360 below:

Baker McKenzie | Dallas, Texas | Image Provided by Gensler

Baker McKenzie's Billing Shift Won't Kick Off Industry Switch

By Daniel Moritz-Rabson

Law360 (November 17, 2026, 4:44 PM EST) -- The announcement that Baker McKenzie is shifting away from the billable hour is unlikely to kick off an industrywide rush to overhaul billing practices, analysts told Law360 Pulse.

Last week, Baker McKenzie Global Chair Sunny Mann told The Wall Street Journal the firm is pushing its attorneys to consider value-based billing models or alternative fee arrangements as the default billing method.

The decision from one of the world's biggest law firms could signal a significant step in the closely watched trend away from the billable hour. But law firm consultants stressed that the extent to which Baker McKenzie's move leads to a cascading change depends on the firm's implementation of its new billing methods and the results of the billing overhaul.

“The proof of the pudding is in the execution, and it's far, far harder than people might think," Richard Burcher, vice president of pricing and profitability at legal software firm Aderant, told Law360Pulse. Other firms "are probably going to wait and see before they rip the floorboards up," he continued.

Details about Baker McKenzie's rollout of alternate billing methods remains to be seen.

The firm did not immediately respond to Law360's questions about what kinds of clients most benefit from alternative fee arrangements or offer additional details on what kinds of billing models it is prioritizing. Value-based billing and AFAs can refer to a wide range of pay arrangements, Burcher noted in a weekend LinkedIn post.

“We see the evolving market as an opportunity to engage innovatively with our clients. Alternative fee arrangements are very much part of the mix we want to offer," a Baker McKenzie spokesperson wrote via email in response to questions sent by Law360 Pulse for this article. “Hourly billing is available where clients prefer it or where it is the most appropriate model for the work. Our focus as a firm is on being responsive to what our clients want."

As with other changes in the legal industry, Burcher said he expects the largest and most profitable firms to start overhauling their fee arrangements before those with smaller headcounts and lower profits change their billing practices, noting that change “cascades down."

Mark Medice, principal at legal consultancy LawVision, noted that the largest firms have offices across the globe, including in markets that embrace AFAs more commonly than the U.S. does. That existing infrastructure can help with the broader shift to new billing methods, he said. Medice said analysts and other law firms will be watching “client adoption, profitability, scalability and competitive advantage" to analyze the success of Baker McKenzie's shift away from the billable hour.

“A key distinction is whether AI enables services to be delivered faster, better or differently,” he told Law360 Pulse via email. “The real test isn't how many matters move away from hourly billing. It's whether the firm creates greater client value while improving its economics and competitive position."

He noted that, while Baker McKenzie can create a “whole library of AFAs," clients need to feel those billing arrangements are beneficial, or they'd continue opting for hourly billing.

Most who offered insights to Law360 Pulse for this article predicted Baker McKenzie's announcement would add momentum to the move away from the billable hour. But some industry experts viewed the announcement more as a public relations exercise than a large development in the debate about billing models.

“There does not appear to be a novel or wholesale transformation taking place," Keith Maziarek, principal at consulting firm Lucratic Method, told Law360 Pulse via email. Maziarek noted that many large law firms have been offering alternative fee arrangements to clients when they make sense since the global financial crisis.

But the prevailing view was that Baker McKenzie's move fuels the push to create alternative billing structures that ensure firms can still reap profits as artificial intelligence speeds up legal work.

“I expect more announcements, but meaningful transformation will take longer. Baker McKenzie is giving other firms permission, and perhaps applying pressure, to reconsider a decades-old model," Medice said.

He added that Baker McKenzie's announcement could also motivate more firms to articulate a stance on alternative billing models.

“What Baker is illustrating is you've got to develop a point of view. There's a lot of firms that don'thave a point of view about this, right? And if there's nothing else, Baker has really illustrated a willingness to have a point of view about it, and I think that's admirable," he said.

Not all legal practices are equally suited for project-based fees.

“If the amount of work is uncertain, such as major litigation, then a fixed fee likely means that some guesses are going to be taken. The best approach that I have seen so far is where the law firm uses AI on its billing data to create budgets and safety nets for both sides and creates some greater certainty whilst accepting flexibility on top," Kevin Doolan, a partner in professional services firm Strategy Four and a consultant to major law firms, told Law360 Pulse via email.

It can be difficult to assess the fairness of project-based fees, which also can create issues that don'temerge with the billable hour, such as when the scope of work changes.

“For both parties to be able to assess non-hourly fees, they need agreed upon scope developmentand scope change processes. Neither of those exist at scale for either party. So how can anyone saywhen a fee is fair or not? Many clients even say under fixed fees they will not accept any changes toit once it is set," Toby Brown, the CEO at DV8 Legal Strategies, told Law360 via email.

For firms that do decide to start prioritizing new payment models, they'll have to overhaul internal systems.

“There is a massive skills development piece that's required," Aderant's Burcher said. "You've got theirretrievably intertwined mix of billable hours targets and firm remuneration meritocracy structures. That's all going to have to be unpacked and rethought. This is serious stuff. None of this is an easy lift."

--Editing by Amy French.

All Content © 2003-2026, Portfolio Media, Inc. 

Next
Next

The End Is Nigh—Or Is It? Experts Debate Law Firm Rate Hikes, AI's Impact and Adaptability